House Price Watch
100 most expensive houses in Cayton
Cayton, a charming part of Scarborough, has seen a remarkable range of property sales over the years. The most expensive house sold for an impressive £700,000 back in 2009, while the least expensive fetched £245,000. With 1673 sales recorded since 1995, the area reflects a vibrant real estate market. Interestingly, 10 of the houses on the list are located on the same street, including Dairy Lane, Forge Close, Star Carr Road, and West Garth. The latest sale was recorded in 2025, showcasing ongoing interest in this lovely community.
Sold in December 2009
killerby hall killerby, north yorkshire
£700,000
Sold in September 2008
ryecroft killerby, north yorkshire
£657,000
Sold in June 2022
castle view killerby cliff, north yorkshire
£650,000
4.
Sold in June 2025
37 main street, north yorkshire
£610,000
5.
Sold in 2008
the beach house killerby cliff, north yorkshire
£600,000
6.
Sold in September 2009
eldin hall osgodby lane, north yorkshire
£600,000
7.
Sold in 2005
killerby old hall killerby, north yorkshire
£500,000
8.
Sold in April 2025
lane end house station road, north yorkshire
£495,000
9.
Sold in December 2002
killerby hall killerby, north yorkshire
£435,000
10.
Sold in October 2021
37 main street, north yorkshire
£420,000
Most expensive houses in areas around Cayton
£1,750,000
150.00%
£1,110,000
58.57%
£1,205,000
72.14%
£580,000
-17.14%
£920,000
31.43%
£1,385,000
97.86%
£1,850,000
164.29%
11.
Sold in November 2004
tudor lodge killerby, north yorkshire
£400,000
12.
Sold in August 2023
152 main street, north yorkshire
£395,000
13.
Sold in March 2008
62 main street, north yorkshire
£378,000
14.
Sold in December 2024
8 fieldside close, north yorkshire
£367,500
15.
Sold in August 2024
78 west garth, north yorkshire
£360,000
16.
Sold in July 2022
42a main street, north yorkshire
£355,000
17.
Sold in December 2022
6 fieldside close, north yorkshire
£350,000
18.
Sold in October 2022
87 main street, north yorkshire
£335,000
19.
Sold in September 2011
lane end house station road, north yorkshire
£335,000
20.
Sold in July 2021
14 dairy lane, north yorkshire
£330,000
21.
Sold in October 2021
3 west garth, north yorkshire
£327,500
22.
Sold in December 2024
11 star carr road, north yorkshire
£325,000
23.
Sold in 2024
7 fieldside close, north yorkshire
£325,000
24.
Sold in September 2021
15 west garth, north yorkshire
£320,000
25.
Sold in December 2017
21 church lane, north yorkshire
£317,500
26.
Sold in March 2022
11 star carr road, north yorkshire
£310,000
27.
Sold in June 2021
16 dairy lane, north yorkshire
£310,000
28.
Sold in June 2019
vale view station road, north yorkshire
£310,000
29.
Sold in 2022
11 senior drive, north yorkshire
£310,000
30.
Sold in September 2021
4 dairy lane, north yorkshire
£306,000
31.
Sold in October 2006
red oaks cayton low road, north yorkshire
£305,000
32.
Sold in December 2003
41 main street, north yorkshire
£300,000
Sold for a lower amount since this price
33.
Sold in December 2003
43 main street, north yorkshire
£300,000
Sold for a lower amount since this price
34.
Sold in March 2015
37 main street, north yorkshire
£300,000
35.
Sold in December 2022
41 jackson close, north yorkshire
£300,000
36.
Sold in September 2021
8 carr house lane, north yorkshire
£300,000
37.
Sold in November 2023
27 carr house lane, north yorkshire
£300,000
38.
Sold in April 2016
3 west garth, north yorkshire
£297,495
39.
Sold in July 2015
14 south garth road, north yorkshire
£294,995
40.
Sold in September 2023
10 greencroft gardens, north yorkshire
£294,000
41.
Sold in August 2015
12 south garth road, north yorkshire
£292,995
42.
Sold in June 2015
14 dairy lane, north yorkshire
£292,995
43.
Sold in July 2025
6 main street, north yorkshire
£292,500
44.
Sold in September 2014
9 star carr road, north yorkshire
£292,495
45.
Sold in October 2013
15 west garth, north yorkshire
£289,995
46.
Sold in October 2013
17 west garth, north yorkshire
£289,995
47.
Sold in October 2014
7 west garth, north yorkshire
£289,995
48.
Sold in October 2021
28 mill lane, north yorkshire
£285,000
49.
Sold in October 2016
41 main street, north yorkshire
£285,000
50.
Sold in August 2022
5 jackson close, north yorkshire
£285,000
51.
Sold in 2020
80 west garth, north yorkshire
£285,000
52.
Sold in August 2024
18a west end view, north yorkshire
£285,000
53.
Sold in June 2023
7 star carr road, north yorkshire
£284,168
54.
Sold in August 2022
8 star carr road, north yorkshire
£280,000
55.
Sold in April 2023
5 star carr road, north yorkshire
£280,000
56.
Sold in February 2021
6 fieldside close, north yorkshire
£280,000
57.
Sold in June 2011
37 main street, north yorkshire
£280,000
58.
Sold in June 2024
7 beverley close, north yorkshire
£280,000
59.
Sold in 2022
37 ernest avenue, north yorkshire
£280,000
60.
Sold in July 2024
34 the pastures, north yorkshire
£280,000
61.
Sold in October 2022
15 station road, north yorkshire
£277,000
62.
Sold in July 2022
11 ernest avenue, north yorkshire
£275,000
63.
Sold in August 2015
16 dairy lane, north yorkshire
£274,995
64.
Sold in August 2022
30 carr house lane, north yorkshire
£270,000
65.
Sold in 2022
52 harford road, north yorkshire
£270,000
66.
Sold in April 2022
barngate killerby, north yorkshire
£270,000
67.
Sold in July 2015
4 dairy lane, north yorkshire
£269,995
68.
Sold in November 2014
11 west garth, north yorkshire
£269,995
69.
Sold in September 2023
32 the pastures, north yorkshire
£268,000
70.
Sold in 2013
6 fieldside close, north yorkshire
£264,995
71.
Sold in 2013
9 west garth, north yorkshire
£263,995
72.
Sold in October 2021
54 west garth, north yorkshire
£262,500
73.
Sold in September 2023
17 fieldside close, north yorkshire
£260,000
74.
Sold in October 2023
108a west garth, north yorkshire
£260,000
75.
Sold in 2022
34 ernest avenue, north yorkshire
£260,000
76.
Sold in March 2023
9 penton road, north yorkshire
£260,000
77.
Sold in December 2013
8 fieldside close, north yorkshire
£259,995
78.
Sold in May 2022
69 west garth, north yorkshire
£257,000
79.
Sold in February 2019
82 main street, north yorkshire
£255,000
80.
Sold in December 2019
6 flowergate drive, north yorkshire
£252,000
81.
Sold in June 2019
8 star carr road, north yorkshire
£250,000
82.
Sold in 2024
floraville killerby cliff, north yorkshire
£250,000
83.
Sold in April 2011
18 north lane, north yorkshire
£250,000
84.
Sold in April 2002
the gatehouse osgodby lane, north yorkshire
£250,000
85.
Sold in 2022
155 west garth, north yorkshire
£250,000
86.
Sold in July 2022
9 ernest avenue, north yorkshire
£250,000
87.
Sold in March 2023
38 ernest avenue, north yorkshire
£250,000
88.
Sold in September 2012
appletree cottage station road, north yorkshire
£250,000
89.
Sold in May 2022
8 senior drive, north yorkshire
£250,000
90.
Sold in June 2020
2 star carr road, north yorkshire
£249,999
91.
Sold in March 2015
6 dairy lane, north yorkshire
£249,995
92.
Sold in December 2013
73 west garth, north yorkshire
£249,995
93.
Sold in October 2013
19 west garth, north yorkshire
£249,995
94.
Sold in June 2019
80a west garth, north yorkshire
£249,950
95.
Sold in July 2021
18 harford road, north yorkshire
£248,000
96.
Sold in June 2014
5 dairy lane, north yorkshire
£247,995
97.
Sold in December 2018
11 star carr road, north yorkshire
£247,000
98.
Sold in May 2014
2 star carr road, north yorkshire
£246,995
99.
Sold in April 2021
1 flowergate drive, north yorkshire
£245,000
100.
Sold in April 2016
9 fieldside close, north yorkshire
£245,000
Data Source & Update Note:
This list of the 100 most expensive homes sold in Cayton is compiled from all-time residential sales recorded by the HM Land Registry. Each entry includes the sale price and transaction date. The dataset was last updated in July 2025 (The latest available from HM Land Registry). Prices reflect actual recorded transactions, not current market valuations.